Sometime after my Celtic foray, I picked up a few gold paints with plans to review. Well, one thing led to another and the gold testing went by the wayside. This evening I experimented with the following paints:
Brand: Winsor and Newton Designers' Gouache
Name: Gold
Description: Titanium dioxide coated mica/ synthetic iron oxides
Brand: Holbein Artists' Gouache
Name: Rich Gold
Description: PW20 PW6
Brand: Holbein Artists' Gouache
Name: Brilliant Gold
Description: PW20 PW6
Brand: Schmincke Horodam Aquarell
Name: Gold
Description: Yellow gold tone. No bronze, but coated mica with metal oxide(Iriodin).
Here's a scan that came out okay. Not a lot of sparkle but it does illustrate color.
And here's a photo with sparkle... and glare (sorry about that...)
Note that the first three rows (WN, Holbein) are gouache, the last (Schmincke) being watercolor. The first column was a wash perhaps a bit too wet. The second was straight from the tube. The third was just a bit of water. Do click on the photos for better viewing.
My favorite for color and application was Holbein Rich Gold; my least favorite for the same reasons was Holbein Brilliant Gold. Brilliant gold seemed to have large chips that left a chunky appearance. WN was decent and probably my number two pick. Schmincke, being a watercolor, seemed to go on lighter. I do like its distinctly lighter color that might come in handy in particular paintings. I absolutely love the Schmincke caps! They're huge with small threaded tubes. So much nicer that those WN beasts that make me keep pliers handy.
I visited Odyssey 2010 this afternoon, meeting vendors and spending money. I'm going back for more tomorrow! Details to follow! :-)
While I obviously can't vouch for the feel of the paint, my favorite of your samples looks to be the Holbein Rich Gold, too. One of my own favorites is one I have had forever it seems; I squeezed out the remainder of the tube into a seashell ( I like to use them as mini palettes ) and now haven't a clue what the actual paint is anymore. I always keep several golds on hand ( qouaches, mostly) to suit the project at hand.
ReplyDelete~gretchen
Actually, I picked up this bunch based on comments from you some time ago. You mentioned how different all the golds were, something that at the time I somehow found surprising--never realizing just how different each paint from each manufacturer could be.
ReplyDelete